Table 4 OBLS workgroup scores for each domain of the agree II assessment and overall approval of the 2015 AHA statement of managing cardiac arrest in pregnancy
Domain | Focus | Score |
|---|---|---|
Domain 1: Scope and Purpose | Evaluates the overall aim, specific health question, and target population of the guideline. | 82% |
Domain 2: Stakeholder Involvement | Evaluates the degree to which the appropriate stakeholders developed the guidelines and represents the views and preferences of the target population | 58% |
Domain 3: Rigor of Development | Relates to the process used to gather and synthesize evidence including grading and summarizing, as well as the methods to formulate recommendations and to update them | 72% |
Domain 4: Clarity Of Presentation | Evaluates the presentation and format of the guidelines including language, structure, and format | 90% |
Domain 5: Applicability | Evaluates the consideration of likely facilitators or barriers to implementation, strategies to address them, and resources needed to apply the guidelines | 65% |
Domain 6: Editorial Independence | Is concerned with the guidelines being formulated without competing interests | 85% |
Overall Assessment | Rating of the overall quality of the guideline and whether the guideline would be recommended for use in practice | 75% |
Approve | Without modifications | 57% |
With modifications | 43% | |
Total | 100% |