Skip to main content

Table 1 Summary of included studies

From: How do interventions to improve the efficiency of acute stroke care affect prehospital times? A systematic review and narrative synthesis

Lead author

Year

Country

Sample Size

Study design

Intervention

Prehospital impact

Risk of bias

Studies targeting EMS dispatch +/− EMS clinicians

 Berglund [16]

2012

Sweden

942 suspected stroke patients

RCT

Increased priority stroke dispatch and rapid transport to stroke unit. Meetings and education prior to study.

Dispatch randomised = shorter call to hospital but no change in OST. EMS randomised = no change.

Some concernsa

 Mohamad [22]

2016

Denmark

476 stroke patients who received thrombolysis and/or thrombectomy

Before and after

EMS dispatch and paramedic training on large vessel occlusion scale and prioritisation

Reduced prehospital delay for thrombectomy but not for thrombolysis (non-significant)

Serious

 Puolakka [25]

2016

Finland

77 thrombolysis candidates

Prospective cohort study

Dispatch of fire and rescue service to support ambulances with stroke patients

Non-significant decrease in OST

Serious

 Watkins [26]

2013

UK

464 suspected or confirmed stroke patients

Interrupted time series

2-hour online training package for dispatchers

No change in call to hospital arrival pre and post implementation, improved recognition of stroke

Moderate

Studies targeting EMS clinicians only

 Frendl [20]

2009

USA

154 suspected stroke patients

Before and after

1-hour educational presentation with written material

No significant change in OST

Critical

 Gorchs-Molist [17]

2020

Spain

17,135 suspected stroke patients

Before and after

6-hours online training

Increased call to hospital time with large % due to OST

Critical

 Oostema [23]

2019

USA

1805 EMS transported patients

Interrupted time series

30-minute online training plus case-based feedback

Increased cases < 15 mins OST, no significant change in overall OST or transport time

Serious

 Puolakka [24]

2016

Finland

289 thrombolysis candidates

Before and after

45-minute training session with interactive follow up group sessions

10% reduction in OST, no change in dispatch to hospital time

Moderate

Studies targeting whole system change

 De Luca [19]

2009

Italy

4895 suspected stroke patients

Cluster RCT

Training on stroke emergency care pathway

Reduced dispatch to hospital

Lowa

 Kendall [21]

2015

UK

351 thrombolysed patients

Before and after

Continuous quality improvement approach

No significant difference in call to door time

Critical

 Wojner-Alexandrov [18]

2005

USA

1518 suspected stroke patients

Before and after

Monthly multilevel education sessions

Increased OST, transport and overall time

Critical

  1. EMS Emergency medical services, OST On-scene time, RCT Randomised controlled trial.
  2. aassessed using ROB2, all other studies assessed using ROBINS-I